How To Negotiate a Job Offer With Confidence

30 Mar 2023

It can be a difficult thing negotiating, especially when there’s lives depending on you. You’ve been told there are 12 people who have been taken hostage by a masked robber in a bank, and it’s up to you to make sure they get out alive. So, what do you do? Well, first you have to… oh, wait – that’s the wrong type of negotiation… never mind.

Fear not, because today we’re talking about negotiating your job offer. So, before you panic, you can relax again knowing that no one’s life is at stake. Because – unlike hostage negotiation – negotiating your job offer will be a walk in the park once you’re finished with this blog post. And don’t worry, the only person that will need to be worried about their bank being taken hostage is your future employer (not literally).

Negotiating a job offer can be a delicate dance between advocating for yourself and not coming across as too pushy or demanding. It’s like trying to find the perfect balance between confidence and humility – a bit like walking a tightrope while juggling flaming torches.

85% of people who counteroffered their job offer were successful, so believe me, you have a good chance of successfully negotiating a higher salary. While it’s likely you’ll successfully negotiate, many people are not even trying to aim for a higher salary, with 55% of candidates not even attempting to negotiate.

Think you’ll catch the employer off guard by making a counteroffer? That’s not the case. 70% of managers expect a negotiation when they make a job offer. In the US, the average employee could be earning $7,528 more per year if they negotiated their salary at the time of hiring.

If you have already got a job that you’re happy with, but want a higher salary, read our article on negotiating a higher salary with your boss.

So, strap on your negotiation boots and get ready to step up to the plate, because with our help, you’ll be able to negotiate like a boss in no time.

Know your worth before accepting a job offer

Before accepting a job offer, it’s important to have a good understanding of your own worth in the job market. This involves researching the average salary range for similar roles in your industry and location. Websites like Glassdoor, Salary.com, and PayScale can provide valuable insights into the compensation packages offered by companies in your field.

It’s also important to consider your own qualifications and achievements. If you have a unique skill set or experience that sets you apart from other candidates, you may be able to negotiate a higher salary or better benefits package. Be prepared to discuss your accomplishments and highlight your strengths during the negotiation process.

In addition to salary, it’s important to evaluate the benefits package offered by the company. Benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, and paid time off can add significant value to your compensation package. Make sure to review the details of the benefits package carefully and ask any questions you may have before accepting the job offer.

By taking the time to research and evaluate your own worth, you can negotiate with confidence and ensure that you are receiving fair compensation for your skills and experience. Remember that accepting a job offer is not just about the salary – it’s about finding a position that aligns with your career goals and offers the support and resources you need to succeed.

Strategies for negotiating a job offer

Negotiating a job offer can be a nerve-wracking experience, but with the right strategies, you can advocate for yourself and secure a better salary and benefits package. Here are some tips to help you negotiate your job offer:

  1. Do your research: Before entering into negotiations, research the industry standard for salaries and benefits in your field and location. This will give you a baseline for what you can reasonably expect, and help you advocate for yourself with confidence.
  2. Prioritise your needs: Identify the most important aspects of the job offer for you, such as salary, benefits, or flexible work arrangements. This will help you focus your negotiations on the areas that matter most to you.
  3. Be flexible: Keep an open mind and be willing to negotiate on multiple aspects of the job offer. For example, if the company can’t meet your salary expectations, they may be able to offer additional holiday time or other benefits instead.
  4. Practice your pitch: Prepare a clear and concise explanation of your value to the company, highlighting your skills, qualifications, and experience. Practice your pitch beforehand so you feel confident and articulate during negotiations. Read our article on how to create a powerful sales pitch.
  5. Know your limits: Set a clear bottom line for what you’re willing to accept, and be prepared to walk away if the company can’t meet your needs. However, be aware that rejecting an offer may burn bridges and impact your future job opportunities, so consider this decision carefully.
  1. Timing is everything: Be strategic about when you initiate negotiations. You don’t want to ask for more too early in the process and risk turning off the employer, but you also don’t want to wait too long and miss your opportunity to negotiate. Consider waiting until you’ve received a formal job offer before starting negotiations.
  2. Be respectful and professional: Negotiations can be tense, but it’s important to remain respectful and professional throughout the process. Avoid making demands or ultimatums, and instead frame your requests as a discussion or a proposal for a mutually beneficial agreement.
  3. Consider non-monetary benefits: In addition to salary, there may be other benefits or perks that can make the job offer more appealing, such as flexible work arrangements, professional development opportunities, or a better work-life balance. Consider negotiating for these benefits if salary negotiations are not successful.
  4. Get it in writing: Once you’ve reached a mutually acceptable agreement, make sure to get the details of the job offer in writing. This will help avoid any confusion or misunderstandings later on.
  5. Follow up: After negotiations are complete and you’ve accepted the job offer, be sure to follow up with the employer to express your appreciation and confirm the details of the agreement. This will help solidify your professional relationship with the employer and ensure a smooth transition into your new job.

Remember, negotiating a job offer is not about being pushy or demanding, but about advocating for yourself and finding a mutually beneficial agreement with the employer. By following these strategies, you can approach job negotiations with confidence and maximise your earning potential.

Dos and Don’ts of Salary Negotiation

Do research pay brackets for similar positions         

Don’t show up unprepared

Do be confident         

Don’t apologise 

Do use positive wording        

Don’t say “No.”

Do embrace silence   

Don’t rush the conversation 

Do ask for advice from others

Don’t lie about how much you earn

Do take notes

Don’t forget written documentation (this may come after the negotiation)  

Do follow up  

Don’t leave without saying thank you

Do focus on collaboration and win-win solutions     

Don’t try to compete

Communicating your counter offer effectively

When communicating a job counter offer, it’s important to do so in a professional and respectful manner. Here are some tips to effectively communicate your job counter offer:

  1. Express your gratitude: Start by thanking the employer for the job offer and expressing your appreciation for the opportunity.
  2. Explain your counter offer: Clearly and concisely explain your counter offer, whether it’s a salary increase, additional benefits, or more time off.
  3. Provide supporting evidence: Provide supporting evidence to justify your counter offer. For example, if you’re requesting a salary increase, research the industry standard for your position and experience level.
  4. Emphasise your value: Highlight your skills, qualifications, and achievements that demonstrate your value to the company. This can help justify your counter offer and show that you’re worth investing in.
  5. Be open to negotiation: Be open to negotiating and finding a mutually beneficial solution. Consider alternative options that may be acceptable to both parties.
  6. Maintain a professional tone: Keep the conversation professional and respectful, even if the employer is unable to meet your counter offer.

Remember, the goal is to have a productive conversation that results in a positive outcome for both parties. By communicating your job counter offer effectively, you can increase your chances of reaching a mutually beneficial agreement.

What to do if negotiations fail

If negotiations fail and you’re unable to reach a mutually acceptable agreement, there are a few options to consider:

  • Accept the original offer: If the employer is unable or unwilling to meet your counter offer, you may need to accept the original offer or risk losing the job opportunity altogether.
  • Consider other options: If you’re not able to accept the original offer, consider other job opportunities that may be available to you. This may include applying to other companies or exploring other job openings in your field.
  • Re-evaluate your priorities: Consider if the job offer is still a good fit for you, even if the salary or benefits are not what you were hoping for. Think about other factors that are important to you, such as the company culture, work-life balance, and growth opportunities.
  • Maintain a professional relationship: Even if negotiations fail, it’s important to maintain a professional relationship with the employer. Thank them for their time and consideration, and leave the door open for future opportunities.

Negotiations don’t always go as planned, but it’s important to handle the situation with professionalism and respect. By staying open-minded and flexible, you can explore alternative options and make the best decision for your career.

Good luck with negotiating your counter offer!

In conclusion, negotiating a job offer can be daunting, but with the right strategies and mindset, you can secure a better salary and benefits package. Researching industry standards and evaluating your own worth is essential to negotiate with confidence.

It’s important to prioritise your needs, be flexible, practice your pitch, know your limits, be strategic with timing, and remain respectful and professional throughout the negotiation process.

Additionally, considering non-monetary benefits can also be beneficial. Remember that accepting a job offer is not just about the salary; it’s about finding a position that aligns with your career goals and offers the support and resources you need to succeed. By following these strategies, you’ll be able to negotiate like a boss in no time.

We hope you’ve enjoyed today’s instalment in the RekkBlog series, and don’t forget to have a read of some of our other RekkBlog posts!

Don’t forget to subscribe to our RekkTalk newsletter, and if you’d like to get in touch, give us a message on Facebook or Linkedin! Otherwise, drop us an email at info@rekkruut.com.